S. LEE MANNING
  • Home
  • Kolya Petrov thrillers
  • Deadly Choice
  • A Killing Couple
  • Blog
  • ABOUT
  • Past Appearances (2023-24)
  • Short Stories
  • Kolya Petrov thrillers

CAN FICTION TEACH about the Holocaust?

6/13/2023

1 Comment

 
Picture
Antisemitism and Holocaust denial have steadily risen in the past few years. The causes are many: the rise of conspiracy theories that always target Jewish people, the normalizing of antisemitism on Twitter and by certain high profile individuals, and the mainstreaming of people with Nazi views who would have in previous days been shunned but now are freely spewing hatred on Twitter and elsewhere. And then there's just plain ignorance - that a shocking number of people in the United States don't know just much about the Jewish people nor do they know the facts of the Holocaust.

In 2020, a survey showed that one in ten people under the age of forty had never heard the term Holocaust. That 63% didn't know that six million Jews were murdered. In New York, California, and Indiana higher than twenty percent thought that the Holocaust was a myth or was exaggerated.

This is happening as the last survivors are quietly disappearing. World War II ended seventy-eight years ago. A person who was twenty at the war's end is ninety-eight now.  A ten year old - who would have old enough to have some memories of what happened - is eighty eight. The American soldiers who fought in that war and who liberated the camps are also disappearing.  Even if the memories are recorded, it's not as strong or as vivid as hearing the personal testimony of someone who either lived through the horror to witnessed its aftermath.

Education - formal and informal - is the way to counter both the prejudice and the ignorance.

While true stories are essential to broadening the knowledge of the consequences of antisemitism, fiction also has a role to play.

With fiction, our empathies are engaged by characters we like and the challenges they face. Sometimes reading a powerful novel is the best way to emotionally pull readers into understanding a social issue. (There is a reason why Abraham Lincoln credited Harriet Beecher Stowe with starting the Civil War, with her novel Uncle Tom's Cabin.)

In my novels featuring Kolya Petrov, the Jewish Russian born immigrant to the United States, I have tried to counter antisemitism by portraying a likable, courageous man who risks his life on behalf of this country - a character who a reader can identify with. In Bloody Soil, I do more than that - I sneak the history of the Holocaust into what is an otherwise thrilling adventure. And I make it personal. When we hear statistics about six million people being murdered, the number is so great that it almost doesn't have an emotional impact. But  every one of those six million men, women, and children had a story, had people they loved, had hopes and dreams. To feel the true horror, we have to see some of those stories. So in Bloody Soil, the story of Kolya's great grandmother being shot in the pit known as Babi Yar - a story that Kolya heard when he was a child -  makes it more real. And while she may be a fictional character, she represents the stories of the very real  over thirty thousand people who were killed at Babi Yar.

I do the same with other aspects of the Holocaust - mentioning the Kindertransport - the ten thousand children who were taken by train to the UK and saved - even though most of their parents perished - the use of the term blood and soil and what it meant - the murder by fire of Jewish people - and the mass murders of the Roma and Sinti.  

But recognizing that some people may not know or recognize the factual undermining to those mentions in Bloody Soil, I created a study guide that explains and expands on the narrative. It's now available on my website  here and a printed version is available from me personally at a  
nominal cost for book clubs or otherwise. (I'm also available to talk on zoom.)

It's up to all of us to fight back against ignorance and prejudice. The history of the Holocaust shows the consequences of a failure to do so.
​



1 Comment
Alicia Butcher Ehrhardt link
10/24/2023 11:27:06 pm

Never forget. The scale of the Holocaust and the evil that created it went to incredible lengths - the Germans have made a start by insisting their children learn about it.

I read somewhere (years back - wonder if it has changed) that Japanese high school history texts didn't mention Pearl Harbor. And many US states are trying to block information about how we treated Native American, Black people, and immigrants from being taught in schools.

It hasn't been until very recently that the offensive Confederate flag and statues honoring racists and anti-semites have been coming down.

Teaching what happened (and I'll include the Spanish Inquisition, and many other religious massacres of individuals and groups) is basic to understanding that our human race CAN and DOES go there - and to work against it.

I'm glad you're doing your share. Fiction is, in my opinion, as good as or better than experience in some cases, because the very process of reading creates identification and empathy, and is a sneaky way to get past some of the barriers of the closed mind. As long as the author doesn't preach.

My particular current one is to make disability more known and better understood - but you'll see my own beliefs in what I write as 'normal': gay couples having and rearing children, acceptance of differences in others, prejudices not being allowed to stand, respect for women... Otherwise the darkness wins.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    January 2024
    July 2023
    June 2023
    April 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    April 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    January 2021
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly